Last week at SQL Connections someone said that CHECKDB’s output is ‘useless’.  Given that I wrote CHECKDB for SQL Server 2005 I was only mildly offended :-) But there’s a lot of truth in that statement – the error messages from CHECKDB do tell you exactly what’s corrupt in the database but they’re not exactly easy to read and understand unless you’re intimately familiar with the on-disk structures used to store a SQL Server database. It’s pretty easy to understand the output if there’s only one or two error messages, but once you get past 10 or so it becomes extremely difficult to figure out what the actual problem is for normal people (i.e. not CHECKDB geeks like me, Ryan or a handful of senior people in Product Support)


So, how are you supposed to figure out what’s wrong? In this post I want to run through a few tips and tricks you can use.



  • If the recommended repair level (at the very bottom of the output) is REPAIR_REBUILD then only non-clustered indexes are damaged. This meanscyou don’t need to run repair (which needs the database in single-user mode) or restore from backups. You can just manually rebuild the damaged indexes to fix the problem, possibly even online if you’re running Enterprise Edition and the index doesn’t have any LOB columns.
  • There are a couple of cases where even if it’s only non-clustered indexes that are damaged, REPAIR_ALLOW_DATA_LOSS may still be the recommended repair option. In this case, check the index ID in all the error messages – if all index IDs are 2 or higher, then it’s only non-clustered indexes that are damaged and you can rebuild them yourself instead of running repair/restore.
  • Figure out a list of tables that are affected by looking at the summary messages about how many corruptions were found per table. If each of the tables is isolated on a separate filegroup then these filegroups can be taken offline and restored individually, possibly without interrupting the application workload. If there’s no backup, then you can run DBCC CHECKTABLE with repair, for a faster repair operation than running a full CHECKDB.
  • Figure out the list of damaged pages. There are a number of error messages that could point to a damaged page – usually 8928 or 2537 – and then you can choose to do single-page restores from your backups to minimize downtime, possibly even online in Enterprise Edition.
  • Are there any errors that CHECKDB can’t repair?  If so, you have no choice but to restore from backups or to extract as much info as possible into a new database. Things to look for that mean repair won’t be able to fix everything are:

    • CHECKDB stops early and complains about system table pre-checks failing (errors 7984 – 7988 inclusive)
    • CHECKDB reports any metadata corruption (8992, 8995 errors)
    • CHECKDB reports any errors on PFS page headers (8939, 8946 errors with a possible 8998 error as well)

While I was at Microsoft I wrote two 200-page+ documents detailing all the CHECKDB error messages for SQL Server 2000 and 2005 – the team says they should all be translated into Books Online entries by next summer – a bunch of them are there already. In the meantime, I hope the hints above will take a little of the mystery out of CHECKDB’s output.